NCERT Solution for Class 10 Science Chapter 9
Heredity and Evolution
NCERT Books for Session 2022-2023
CBSE Board and UP Board
Exercises Questions
Page No-159
Questions No-4
A study found that children with light-coloured eyes are likely to have parents with light-coloured eyes. On this basis, can we say anything about whether the light eye colour trait is dominant or recessive? Why or why not?
Share
The observation that children with light-colored eyes are likely to have parents with light-colored eyes suggests that the trait for light eye color may be inherited in a manner consistent with Mendelian genetics. However, this observation alone is not sufficient to determine whether light eye color is a dominant or recessive trait.
In Mendelian genetics, traits can be either dominant or recessive. Here’s a brief explanation of each:
. Dominant Trait: A dominant trait is expressed when an individual has at least one copy of the dominant allele. In the case of eye color, if light eye color were dominant, then individuals with one or two copies of the light eye color allele would have light-colored eyes.
. Recessive Trait: A recessive trait is only expressed when an individual has two copies of the recessive allele. If light eye color were recessive, individuals would need to inherit two copies of the light eye color allele from their parents to have light-colored eyes.
The observation you mentioned can be explained by several scenarios:
1. Light eye color is dominant:
In this case, if both parents have light-colored eyes, they will pass on at least one copy of the light eye color allele to their children. As a result, children are likely to have light-colored eyes if their parents have light-colored eyes.
2. Light eye color is recessive:
. Even if light eye color is a recessive trait, if both parents have light-colored eyes, they will only possess the recessive allele for light eye color. Since they can only pass on the recessive allele, their children are likely to have light-colored eyes if they inherit two copies of the recessive allele.
3. Incomplete dominance or codominance:
. It’s also possible that eye color is determined by more complex genetic mechanisms involving incomplete dominance or codominance. In such cases, the inheritance patterns are more nuanced and may not fit a simple dominant-recessive model.
To conclusively determine whether light eye color is dominant or recessive, a more detailed genetic analysis would be required. Specifically, one would need to study the inheritance patterns in a large population, conduct genetic crosses, and analyze the distribution of eye colors in multiple generations. Without this additional information, it’s not possible to definitively establish the mode of inheritance for light eye color based solely on the observation that children with light-colored eyes tend to have parents with light-colored eyes.
On the basis of population study whichever trait is more prevalent is the dominant one. In this case, the study says that light eye coloured children have light eyed parents. this clearly shows that is recessive trait so that both parents give the recessive gene for the child also to be homozygous recessive.
This information is not sufficient. For considering a trait as dominant or recessive, we need data of at least three generations. This data is about only two generations.
Let us assume that children with light – coloured eyes can either have LL or Ll or ll
genotype. If the children have LL genotype, then their parents will also be of LL genotype.
LL × LL
↓
LL
If the children with light-coloured eyes have ll genotype, then their parents will also have
ll genotype.
ll × ll
↓
ll
Therefore, it cannot be concluded whether light eye colour is dominant or recessive.
For more answers visit to website:
https://www.tiwariacademy.com/ncert-solutions/class-10/science/chapter-9/