Home/ Questions/Q 509258
Next
In Process
Virat
  • 2
Asked: 2025-07-24T11:12:18+00:00 In:

Once upon a time, there was a king who was very fond of horses. He had 20 horses of the best breed. The horses were kept in the royal stable, and cared for by a caretaker. One night, a thief stole one of the horses. Fearing punishment, the caretaker arranged the horses in the stable as shown in the picture here. The next day, when the king came to check on the horses, the caretaker led him around the square stable. “Please count the number of horses along each side, your majesty,” he said. The king counted 5 horses along each side. “We have 5 horses along each side and there are 4 sides. So there are a total of 20 horses, your majesty,” the caretaker explained. Satisfied with the explanation, the king returned to his palace. But wait, were there really 20 horses in the stable? Count the horses one by one and check! What was the mistake in the caretaker’s explanation? The following night, the thief stole another horse from the stable. Now, only 18 horses remained. The caretaker once again cleverly arranged the 18 horses, so that there were 5 horses on each side of the square stable. How do you think he was able to do it? Arrange the 18 horses in the stable with 5 on each side. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king notices something is wrong? Try making the arrangements yourself. Here are the two questions to be answered: 1. How did the caretaker arrange 18 horses so that each side had 5 horses? 2. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king finds out?

  • 2
Once upon a time, there was a king who was very fond of horses. He had 20 horses of the best breed. The horses were kept in the royal stable, and cared for by a caretaker. One night, a thief stole one of the horses. Fearing punishment, the caretaker arranged the horses in the stable as shown in the picture here. The next day, when the king came to check on the horses, the caretaker led him around the square stable. “Please count the number of horses along each side, your majesty,” he said. The king counted 5 horses along each side. “We have 5 horses along each side and there are 4 sides. So there are a total of 20 horses, your majesty,” the caretaker explained. Satisfied with the explanation, the king returned to his palace. But wait, were there really 20 horses in the stable? Count the horses one by one and check! What was the mistake in the caretaker’s explanation? The following night, the thief stole another horse from the stable. Now, only 18 horses remained. The caretaker once again cleverly arranged the 18 horses, so that there were 5 horses on each side of the square stable. How do you think he was able to do it? Arrange the 18 horses in the stable with 5 on each side. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king notices something is wrong? Try making the arrangements yourself. Here are the two questions to be answered: 1. How did the caretaker arrange 18 horses so that each side had 5 horses? 2. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king finds out?

The caretaker cleverly placed 18 horses so that each corner horse was shared by two sides. By putting two horses in each corner and two in the middle of each side, the king saw 5 horses per side. This smart overlapping made 18 look like 20. The king never realized!

Class 5 Mathematics Maths-Mela We the Travellers — I

Class 5 Mathematics Maths-Mela Chapter 1 We the Travellers — 1 question answer

arrange the 18 horses in the stable with 5 on each sidemany more horses can the thief steal before the king notices something is wrong
Share

    2 Answers

    1. Once upon a time, there was a king who was very fond of horses. He had 20 horses of the best breed. The horses were kept in the royal stable, and cared for by a caretaker. One night, a thief stole one of the horses. Fearing punishment, the caretaker arranged the horses in the stable as shown in the picture here. The next day, when the king came to check on the horses, the caretaker led him around the square stable. “Please count the number of horses along each side, your majesty,” he said. The king counted 5 horses along each side. “We have 5 horses along each side and there are 4 sides. So there are a total of 20 horses, your majesty,” the caretaker explained. Satisfied with the explanation, the king returned to his palace. But wait, were there really 20 horses in the stable? Count the horses one by one and check! What was the mistake in the caretaker’s explanation? The following night, the thief stole another horse from the stable. Now, only 18 horses remained. The caretaker once again cleverly arranged the 18 horses, so that there were 5 horses on each side of the square stable. How do you think he was able to do it? Arrange the 18 horses in the stable with 5 on each side. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king notices something is wrong? Try making the arrangements yourself. Here are the two questions to be answered: 1. How did the caretaker arrange 18 horses so that each side had 5 horses? 2. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king finds out?

      2. ANSWER : From 18 horses 4 more horses thief can be stolen. Using the clever corner-sharing trick, the caretaker can still arrange up to 14 horses so that the king sees 5 horses on each side. But if the thief steals more and the number goes below 14, it won’t be possible to place 5 horses per side. Class 5 Maths Mela Chapter 1: We the Travellers — I teaches that the trick works only when horses are shared at the corners. So, only (20-6) = 14, i.e. 6 more horses can be stolen from the total.

      • 100
    2. Once upon a time, there was a king who was very fond of horses. He had 20 horses of the best breed. The horses were kept in the royal stable, and cared for by a caretaker. One night, a thief stole one of the horses. Fearing punishment, the caretaker arranged the horses in the stable as shown in the picture here. The next day, when the king came to check on the horses, the caretaker led him around the square stable. “Please count the number of horses along each side, your majesty,” he said. The king counted 5 horses along each side. “We have 5 horses along each side and there are 4 sides. So there are a total of 20 horses, your majesty,” the caretaker explained. Satisfied with the explanation, the king returned to his palace. But wait, were there really 20 horses in the stable? Count the horses one by one and check! What was the mistake in the caretaker’s explanation? The following night, the thief stole another horse from the stable. Now, only 18 horses remained. The caretaker once again cleverly arranged the 18 horses, so that there were 5 horses on each side of the square stable. How do you think he was able to do it? Arrange the 18 horses in the stable with 5 on each side. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king notices something is wrong? Try making the arrangements yourself. Here are the two questions to be answered: 1. How did the caretaker arrange 18 horses so that each side had 5 horses? 2. How many more horses can the thief steal before the king finds out?

      1. How did the caretaker arrange 18 horses so that each side had 5 horses?

      The caretaker arranged the horses along the boundary so each side counted five. Similar trick as for 19 horses. Corner horses were counted double in corners. Some corners are blank. Altogether, the caretaker cleverly arranged 18 horses in such a way that the king would believe that there were 20 horses kept there.

       

      For more NCERT Solutions for Class 5 Mathematics Maths-Mela Chapter 1: We the Travellers — I  Extra Questions & Answer:

      https://www.tiwariacademy.com/ncert-solutions/class-5/maths/

       

       

      • 0
    Leave an answer

    Leave an answer

    Browse