hardikk
  • 0
Poll

In Keeping Quiet, what does the poet mean by victory with no survivors?

  • 0

Poll Results

18.92%Winning a battle without any loss of life. ( 7 voters )
5.41%Gaining success without any impact. ( 2 voters )
62.16%Wars where there is no one left to celebrate victory. ( 23 voters )
13.51%Victory that brings happiness to everyone. ( 5 voters )
Based On 37 Votes

Participate in Poll, Choose Your Answer.

In Keeping Quiet, when the poet Pablo Neruda refers to “victory with no survivors,” he is highlighting the destructive nature of human conflict and competition. He imagines a scenario where, in the pursuit of victory, no one truly wins, as the consequences of war or violence leave everyone harmed or defeated. This phrase suggests that true victory should not come at the cost of destruction and loss. Instead, the poet advocates for peace and introspection, where people come together in unity, and no one is left as a “survivor” of destruction.

This question related to Poem 2 English Flamingo Class 12th NCERT.
From the Poem 2. Keeping Quiet.
Give answer according to your understanding.

Share

2 Answers

  1. The phrase points to the futility of war, where the cost is so high that even victory has no meaning because no one survives to witness it. Therefore option C is correct answer.

    For more please visit here:
    https://www.tiwariacademy.com/ncert-solutions/class-12/english/poem-2/

    • 17
  2. The statement “victory with no survivors” indicates those people have adopt a new approch towards life and to realize that killing so many peole is not a victory. The poet “Neruda” requests people not to involve in wars because there is not benefit of such victory where no one is left alive.

    • 0
Leave an answer

Leave an answer

Browse